A substantial modification is the modification of a machine or related product, by physical or digital means, after it has been placed on the market or put into service, that is not provided for or planned by the manufacturer and that affects safety by creating a new danger or increasing the existing risk, to the point of making it necessary either to add protective devices or protective devices whose implementation requires modifying the existing safety control system, or additional protective measures for stability or mechanical resistance. This is the definition of Article 3, point 16, of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 on machinery, which applies from January 20, 2027. Any person who makes a substantial modification is considered a manufacturer for the relevant machine (Article 18).
In short
- Regulation 2023/1230 defines substantial modification; Directive 2006/42/EC, which it replaces, did not do so.
- Four cumulative conditions: after the placing on the market or putting into service, not foreseen by the manufacturer, a new danger or an increased risk, and a protective measure of a specific type becoming necessary.
- A software modification can be substantial: the text refers to «physical or digital» means.
- The author of the modification, including an operator who transforms his own machine, assumes the obligations of the manufacturer: risk assessment, conformity assessment procedure, EU declaration of conformity, CE marking.
What the text says
Article 3, point 16, of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 defines substantial modification as «the modification of a machine or a related product, by physical or digital means, after the placing on the market or the putting into service of that machine or that related product, which is not foreseen or planned by the manufacturer and which affects the safety of the machine or the related product by creating a new danger or increasing the existing risk, which makes it necessary to:
- a) the addition of protective devices or safeguards to said machine or to the related product, the implementation of which requires the modification of the existing safety control system; or
- b) the adoption of additional protective measures aimed at ensuring the stability or mechanical resistance of said machine or said related product.»
Article 18 follows from this: «A natural or legal person who makes a substantial modification to a machine or to a related product is considered a manufacturer for the purposes of this Regulation.» It is subject to the obligations of Article 10 for that machine, or, if the modification only affects the safety of a machine that is part of a machine assembly, for the affected machine, «as demonstrated by the risk assessment.».
The same Article 18 specifies that it «declares under its sole responsibility» that the machine meets the applicable requirements, and that it applies the conformity assessment procedure provided for in Article 25, paragraphs 2, 3 and 4. One exception: the non-professional user who modifies his machine for his own use is not considered a manufacturer.
The four criteria, one by one
1. It intervenes after the placing on the market or the putting into service
A modification made during design or manufacture, before the first placing on the market, is not a substantial modification: it is part of the manufacturer’s project, which integrates it into its risk assessment.
2. It is not provided for or planned by the manufacturer
Changing a tool provided in the instructions manual, activating an option described by the manufacturer, switching from one format to another within the stated limits: these are planned modifications. The assessment of the risks associated with them is already covered by the instructions manual. This is why the instructions manual is so important, as it sets out what the manufacturer has planned.
3. It creates a new danger or increases the existing risk
A modification that has no effect on safety, such as replacing a part with an identical part, is not substantial.
4. It makes a specific type of protection measure necessary
This is the most discriminant criterion. The new danger or the increased risk must require:
- either protective devices or protective devices whose implementation requires modifying the existing security control system ;
- either additional protective measures for the stability or the mechanical resistance.
If the increased risk is addressed by a fixed protector that does not interfere with the safety control system, and without additional measures for stability or mechanical resistance, the modification is not substantial within the meaning of the regulation. Nevertheless, it must be evaluated and documented.
What this changes for the manufacturer, integrator and operator
For the operator who transforms his machine
An enterprise that increases the speed of a press, adds a robot to a line, or modifies a machine’s program for a new use becomes a manufacturer if the modification is substantial. It must then:
- carrying out the risk assessment of the modified machine (Annex III, general principles);
- apply the relevant conformity assessment procedure (Article 25), which may require a notified body if the machine falls under Annex I, Part A;
- establish the technical documentation (Annex IV, Part A) and update the instruction manual;
- draw up a new EU declaration of conformity, the model of which expressly provides for the mention of a «machine subject to substantial modification» (Annex V, Part A), and affix the CE marking.
For the integrator
The integrator who modifies an existing machine for their client, without it being planned by the original manufacturer, is in the same situation. It is the person who makes the modification who bears the obligations (article 18): it is better for the contract to clearly state who plays this role.
For the original manufacturer
Obligations related to a substantial modification pass to the person who brings it about (article 18). His instructions, describing the normal use, the settings and the intended options, draw the line between what is intended and what is not.
And what if the modification is not substantial?
The Labour Code continues to apply to the employer: work equipment «must be kept in a state of conformity with the technical rules of design and construction applicable at the time of its commissioning in the establishment, including with regard to the instructions for use» (article R4322-1). Therefore, a non-substantial modification must leave the machine compliant with these rules. It is better to assess it, document it and record it in the single risk assessment document.
Two examples
Example 1, substantial. An enterprise adds an automatic loading station, with a robot, to a machining machine delivered for manual loading. The robot’s moving area creates a new danger; protecting it requires an intangible barrier connected to the machine’s safety control system. The four criteria are met: the enterprise becomes the manufacturer of the modified machine.
Example 2, non-substantial. The same company replaces the motor of the broach with a motor with identical characteristics, as specified in the manual. No new danger, no increased risk: this is not a substantial modification. The intervention is recorded in the maintenance logbook.
These examples are fictitious and simplified. Each case is judged based on the evaluation of the risks of the actual machine.
Common mistakes
- Believing that a software modification is never substantial. The text specifically refers to «digital» means: a program change that modifies speeds, zones, or safety functions can be considered such.
- Reasoning based on the sheer scale of the work. A costly modification may not be substantial; a minor modification of the program may be. Only the criteria of Article 3, point 16, count.
- Not documenting the analysis When it is concluded that a modification is not substantial. In the event of an inspection or an accident, it is the written record of the reasoning that allows the decision to be justified.
- Forget the instruction manual. A modified machine whose manual still describes the original machine deceives the operator.
- To think that the substantial modification only concerns new machines. By definition, it concerns machines that are already on the market or in service.
Substantial modification and compliance: what difference?
The compliance of a machine in service consists of bringing it back to the level of the rules that applied when it was put into service, without changing what it does. Substantial modification changes the machine itself and creates a new danger or increases a risk. A compliance can remain an operator’s intervention; a substantial modification makes the operator a manufacturer, with all the obligations of the regulation.
Related terms: manufacturer, quasi-machine, Retrofitting, machine compliance check, compliance assessment, instruction manual, EU declaration of conformity, residual risk.
Frequently asked questions
Who decides whether a change is substantial?
The person who makes the modification, based on the risk assessment of the modified machine. The regulation does not provide for prior authorization: it sets criteria (article 3, point 16) and consequences (article 18). The analysis must be written and kept.
Can a software update be a substantial change?
Yes. The definition refers to modifications «by physical or digital means». An update planned or planned by the manufacturer, and covered by its risk assessment, is not a substantial modification. The mere fact that it comes from the manufacturer is not enough. An unplanned reprogramming that creates a danger and requires modifying the safety control system can be a substantial modification.
What should be done after a substantial change?
Re-take the manufacturer’s obligations for the affected machine (Articles 10 and 18): risk assessment, conformity assessment procedure of Article 25, technical documentation, updated instruction manual, EU declaration of conformity and CE marking.
Will the rule apply before January 20, 2027?
No. Articles 3 and 18 of Regulation 2023/1230 apply from 20 January 2027. Until then, Directive 2006/42/EC remains the reference text for marketing; it does not define substantial modification. The employer remains bound by the Labour Code (article R4322-1).
Does an individual who modifies their machine become a manufacturer?
No. Article 18 excludes the non-professional user who modifies their machine for their own use. The rule applies to professionals.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 on machinery, consolidated text of 27 July 2026 Article 3 (point 16), Articles 10, 18 and 25, Annex I, Annex III (Part A and General Principles), Annex IV Part A, Annex V Part A (EUR-Lex)
- Directive 2006/42/CE on machinery (EUR-Lex)
- Labour Code: R4322-1 (Digital Labour Code)
Current definition as of November 6, 2026. It does not replace the reading of the official text. Find our articles on the documentation machine and our webinar Machine Regulations 2023/1230: What changes on January 20, 2027.
By Philippe, regulatory expert at Optima AI. You are modifying a machine and need to update its documentation? Optima Doc Update, in, within Optima Compliance, Our compliance machine offer reads the original notice and the description of the modification, provides an indicative opinion on its substantiality, which you validate, and rewrites only the relevant chapters. It is offered in a pilot version, with accompanying documentation.